1. What is Overfitting?
Definition of Overfitting
Overfitting refers to the phenomenon where a model becomes overly tailored to the training data, resulting in inaccurate predictions on unseen data (such as test data or real-world operational data). This is a common issue in data analysis and machine learning, especially with predictive models and automated trading systems.
In simple terms, it refers to a state where one is overly fixated on past data and cannot adapt to future data.
Reasons Why Overfitting Occurs
Overfitting is more likely to occur in the following situations:
- Overly Complex Models: Models with an unnecessary number of parameters tend to learn the fine details of the training data.
- Insufficient Data: When training data is scarce, models tend to overlearn the limited data patterns.
- Overreacting to Noise: Models may learn the noise in the training data and treat it as important information.
Relationship with Curve Fitting
Curve fitting refers to applying a formula or function optimized for a specific dataset, but if taken too far, it becomes overfitting. In particular, excessive curve fitting fails to reflect general data trends and instead draws a curve specific to that particular dataset.
2. Risks of Over-Optimization
What is Over-Optimization?
Over-optimization refers to the state where a model or parameters are overly optimized for data used in backtesting, resulting in an inability to achieve expected results in real operational environments. This can also be considered a form of overfitting.
Specific Risks of Over-Optimization
- Performance Degradation in Live Operations: Even if backtests show high results, the system may fail entirely on unseen data.
- Decline in Predictive Accuracy: Models that rely on specific data cannot correctly predict new data patterns.
- Waste of Resources: Even if significant time and cost are spent on development and operations, the results may ultimately be useless.
Areas Where Over-Optimization Is Particularly Problematic
- FX Automated Trading: When a system is optimized based on historical market data, it may fail to adapt to changing market conditions.
- Machine Learning Models: Over-optimized algorithms may be accurate on training data but exhibit high error rates on real data.
3. Measures to Prevent Overfitting
Adopting Simple Models
Limiting model complexity is one of the most effective ways to prevent overfitting. For example, the following approaches are available:
- Limit the number of parameters
- Remove unnecessary variables
- Adopt simple algorithms (e.g., linear regression)
Conducting Out-of-Sample Tests
By clearly separating training data from test data, you can evaluate the model’s generalization performance. Testing the model on ‘new’ data not present in the training set allows you to verify the possibility of overfitting.
Utilizing Cross-Validation
Cross-validation is a method that splits the dataset into multiple parts and alternately uses each part as test data and training data. This technique allows for model evaluation that is not biased toward any particular portion of the data.
Thorough Risk Management
By strengthening risk management, you can minimize losses due to over-optimization. Specifically, the following methods are effective:
- Limit position size
- Set stop-loss orders
- Execute trades based on pre-defined rules
4. Real-World Cases and Success Stories
Examples of Successful Models
In one machine learning model, adopting a simple linear regression yielded better real-world results than a complex neural network. This is because the model was designed to prioritize generalization performance.
Examples Where Countermeasures Took Effect
In a specific FX automated trading system, using cross-validation and simple parameter settings enabled performance in live operation that was almost identical to past backtests.
5. Summary
Overfitting and over-optimization are common challenges in data analysis, machine learning, and FX automated trading. However, by understanding these risks and implementing appropriate countermeasures, you can significantly improve performance in real-world operations. Actively adopt simple models and techniques such as cross-validation, and apply them to your own projects.
Related Articles
目次 1 1. 前言2 2. OrderSend 函式是什麼2.1 OrderSend 函式的基本結構2.2 基本回傳值2.3 OrderSend 函式的作用3 3. OrderSend 函式的參數詳細說明3.1 各參數的詳細說明3.1.1 1. symbol（貨幣對）3.1.2 2. cmd（買賣類型／訂單類型）3.1.3 3. volume（手數）3.1.4 4. price（訂單價格）3.1 […]
目次 1 1. はじめに2 2. MathRound関数とは？2.1 MathRound関数の基本情報2.2 MathRound関数が選ばれる理由3 3. MathRound関数の基本的な使い方3.1 MathRound関数の例3.2 丸めルールの詳細4 4. 他の丸め関数との比較4.1 MathCeil（切り上げ）との違い4.2 MathFloor（切り捨て）との違い4.3 MathRoundと […]
目次 1 1. Giriş2 2. MathRound Fonksiyonu Nedir?2.1 MathRound Fonksiyonu Hakkında Temel Bilgiler2.2 MathRound Fonksiyonunu Seçme Nedenleri3 3. MathRound Fonksiyonunun Temel Kullanımı3.1 MathRound Fonksiy […]
目次 1 1. 前言1.1 MQL 程式設計是什麼？1.2 自動交易與交易策略的重要性2 2. MQL 程式設計概述2.1 MQL 的歷史與 MetaTrader 的關係2.2 MQL4 與 MQL5 的差異與選擇3 3. 開始 MQL 程式設計的準備3.1 必要工具與安裝步驟3.2 初學者應了解的 MQL 程式設計前置知識3.3 首先要學會的基本語法4 4. 實務程式開發4.1 初學者簡易 EA […]
目次 1 1. Was ist Overfitting?1.1 Definition von Overfitting1.2 Gründe, warum Overfitting auftritt1.3 Beziehung zur Kurvenanpassung2 2. Risiken der Überoptimierung2.1 Was ist Überoptimierung?2.2 Spezifi […]
